‘Resilience is very different than being numb. Resilience means you experience, you feel, you fall, you fail, you hurt. You fall. But, you keep going.’
I lived in Queens NY for many years. NYC is where I went to grad school for art therapy and began my career as an art therapist. The city held many possibilities and I had countless experiences there. However, one of the things I missed most while living in the city was nature. As much as I loved spending time in Central Park and other parks, I missed the ocean, getting lost in the woods, or being able to step outside and right into a backyard.
The longer I lived in the city, the more I began seeking out nature in the smallest of places. Whenever I walked around our neighborhood I would pay extra attention to any plants, trees, or animals I came across. Some of my favorite discoveries were of little wildflowers growing out of the pavement, hidden gardens behind neighbor’s fences, or ivy tendrils poking through fences along the sidewalk. I was struck by how resilient and persistent the nature in the city was. Nature adapted to life in the city, much like people adapt to the places they live.
Now my family and I live in Massachusetts and I have plenty of access to a backyard, woods, the ocean, farms, and rivers. However I still think about the glimpses of nature that I came across in the ‘concrete jungle’ of NYC. Lately I’ve been using the inspiration from my city walks by incorporating it into some of my art therapy groups.
In my art therapy groups at the inpatient psychiatric hospital that I work at, I’ve been creating new art therapy group themes based on positive psychology principles. Positive psychology has drawn increasing attention in the past number of years and is often a challenging idea to explain to clients. Many group members assume that it’s about focusing on the good while ignoring the bad. I think the following explanation from Christopher Peterson, PhD is clarifying and helpful:
‘Positive psychology is the scientific study of what makes life most worth living. It is a call for psychological science and practice to be as concerned with strength as with weakness; as interested in building the best things in life as in repairing the worst; and as concerned with making the lives of normal people fulfilling as with healing pathology.
Nowhere does this definition say or imply that psychology should ignore or dismiss the very real problems that people experience. Nowhere does it say or imply that the rest of psychology needs to be discarded or replaced. The value of positive psychology is to complement and extend the problem-focused psychology that has been dominant for many decades.’
When doing art therapy work with a positive psychology lens, I keep returning to the theme of resilience. Resilience is a process of moving through difficult or traumatic experiences and adapting and growing. Resilience can be cultivated in individuals and strengthened. Part of that process involves helping clients realize the ways in which they are already resilient.
Within the predominant medical model of mental health, there is usually a focus on ‘what’s wrong’ with people and how to fix it, rather than ‘what’s right’ with people. I believe that a well-rounded approach to mental health must embrace both areas. All of us have room for improvement, but it’s also important to spend time acknowledging the strengths and positive qualities that we already possess.
I was finding that many of my art therapy group members had a hard time identifying positive aspects of themselves. Many of them are experiencing a psychological crisis and currently overwhelmed by stressors. I realized that using the metaphor of resilience in nature could be a useful emotional bridge within a group setting.
Art Therapy Group: Resilience In Nature
I begin the group by placing several nature photographs in the center of the table. The photos represent examples of resilience in nature and include things like: small flowers growing through concrete, new growth after a forest fire, and trees that learned to bend in harsh environments and weather instead of breaking. I let the group members explore them, compare them, and make free associations. I’ve been amazed by how strongly people react to them and how quickly emotions emerge, before we’ve even began art making. After a minute or two I begin asking the group questions such as:
What do these images have in common?
Do they remind you of anything?
Have you ever seen nature like this yourself?
Is there one image that you find yourself particularly drawn to and why?
How did these (flowers, trees, rocks) have to adapt in order to survive?
Usually the group members automatically pick up on the shared theme of resilience. Even if that word is not mentioned, other words such as ‘strength, flexibility, and enduring’ come up. I spend a few minutes talking about resilience and how it relates to positive psychology and our work in this group.
The Art Process
After discussing the images and talking about the theme of resilience, I ask each person to think about the ways they are resilient. Once they have thought about themselves in this way, I ask them to come up with an image from nature that represents their personal resilience. It’s a symbolic self-portrait, using nature for inspiration. I encourage them to come up with a unique example from nature that might be different from the photographs we explored. Sometimes a client has a hard time coming up with their own image from scratch, and so I tell them it’s ok to borrow directly from a photograph that resonated with them. I encourage them to draw it mindfully while paying attention to the small details they might add.
In terms of art materials, I have done this with both wet materials such as acrylic and watercolor and dry materials such as colored pencils, oil pastels, and markers. Painting tends to evoke more feelings and greater discussion. Since I don’t always have long group time slots at the hospital, I have found that watercolor crayons can offer a happy middle ground between drawing and painting. They can be dipped directly into water to create a watercolor style line or you can draw with them and then go over the drawing with a wet paintbrush.
Absorbing Strength & Finding Meaning
While group members work on their drawings or paintings, there tend to be organic conversations about the images that are emerging. I enjoy helping the clients process their observations and experiences in the moment by asking questions that help them move more deeply into their art. I always leave time after everyone has finished their art to collectively view and talk about the work. Part of the power in art therapy groups is witnessing one another’s art while sharing experiences.
I’ve found that this art therapy directive has led to some of the most moving group experiences I’ve experienced at the hospital. I think this has to do with the group members feeling seen through their resiliency images and acknowledged for their struggles as well as their inner strength. Using nature as a metaphor helps clients create deep personal meaning, without having to disclose specific traumas within a short term acute setting.
As always, I love hearing your experiences – whether personal or in your own art therapy work with clients. Have you explored resilience using art or any other creative modality? Which examples of resilience in nature do you personally identify with? Next time you’re out for a walk – whether in the city or out in nature – keep your eyes open for your own examples. They’ll probably start popping up everywhere!